THE INDEX

This is a space for all things that inspire us and we hope will inspire you too. Have something you'd like us to cover or try? Just contact us!

welcome to OUR blog

CATEGORIES

Niagara Region 

Home Decor

Floral Design 

Seasonal Recipes

Lifestyle 

THREADS & BLOOMS

ABOUT 

portfolio

HOME

Experience

curated shop

Contact

blog

THE INDEX

Hosting

Gardening

Homemade Pop Tarts for Valentine’s Day

This is a recipe for the best homemade pop tarts ever!! What makes this homemade pop tart SO great? This post also covers how to make pastry dough and how to make buttercream icing…the (not so) secret ingredients!

Homemade pop tarts with a Valentine's Day twist
Are you looking for a Valentine’s Day Treat? Try These Homemade Pop Tarts!

With Valentine’s day around the corner I wondered what kind of cute and delicious treat I could make. I wanted something that would start the day and get you in the Valentine’s Day spirit. Homemade pop tarts seemed like the perfect thing to do just that!

Homemade pop tarts with a Valentine's Day twist

Ingredients for 8 Homemade Pop Tarts:

For the Pastry dough:
– 2 cups flour
– cup of unsalted butter cubed and chilled (1 small stick)
– 1 teaspoon salt
– 1 teaspoon sugar
– 4 tablespoons cold water

For the filling:
– 8 tablespoons strawberry jam (strawberry preserves)
– fresh strawberries

For the Buttercream Icing:
– 1 cup confectioners sugar
– 3 tablespoons butter (softened)
– 2 tablespoons milk
– 1/2 teaspoon vanilla

Homemade pop tarts and how to make pastry dough

How to Make Pastry Dough

If you are wondering how to make pastry dough, this recipe is for sure for you! To make the dough, whisk together the flour, salt, and sugar in a bowl. Add in the butter, using a mixer or 2 knives. ‘Cut’ the butter into the flour mixture entirely until it forms even clumps. Add in your water, 1 tablespoon at a time and continue to mix. I find at this point mixing with my hands can be helpful (yes, this is against all pastry making rules, but it works for me!). When the pastry dough is made, gather it into a ball, cover with plastic wrap and place in the fridge to chill for about an hour. Now you know how to make pastry dough!

Roll out half of the dough on a clean surface which is lightly floured. Cut rectangles that are approximately 3″x5″. These are the base of your pop tarts. Place your pop tarts evenly on a baking tray that is lined with parchment paper.


Mmmm, now that you know how to make pastry dough the sky is the limit! I suggest you try this peach galette recipe to start though 😉


Add Jam to Your Homemade Pop Tarts

Use the strawberry jam of your choice and spread it thinly, 1 tablespoon on each base. Thinly slice strawberries and lay them on top of the jam. This is a lovely fresh touch. Note of caution: if you add too much jam it will spill out the sides of the tart and get all over your pan. If this happens to you, be sure to remove your pop tarts from the pan quickly to prevent them from sticking when the excess jam hardens. (Can you tell this happened to me? hehe!).

Put the jam covered pop tart bases into the fridge to chill while you roll out the top dough. Again, cut the dough into 3″x5″ rectangles and place the tops on jam covered bases. Using a fork, seal the edges of your homemade pop tarts.

Pre heat the oven to 350 degrees and place the tray in the bottom half of an oven. Bake until the edges of your homemade pop tarts are slightly brown; it should take about 25 minutes.

Homemade pop tarts and how to make buttercream icing

How to make Buttercream Icing

Buttercream icing is the best and definitely makes these homemade pop tarts! However, any icing will be great for this recipe so feel free to prepare icing in your desired method. I went for buttercream icing. This is made with confectioners sugar, milk, and butter in the amount listed above. Combine all the ingredients in a bowl completely. I added one drop of red food colouring to make the icing a festive soft pink and topped the homemade pop tarts with heart shaped sprinkles. Allow the tarts to cool slightly before icing.

What could be better than warm homemade pop tarts? Happy Valentine’s Day!

Homemade pop tarts with a Valentine's Day twist

As always, the lovely plates and napkins in my blog post are from Anthropologie!


Follow us on Instagram for Daily Updates & Inspiration!

comments +

  1. […] up I never ate pop tarts but once I tried making them myself, (first ever attempt here – still a great recipe!), they quickly became one of my favourite sweet treats to make. While […]

  2. […] Looking for another idea for Valentine’s Day? Try these delicious Homemade Pop Tarts! […]

  3. […] for other sweet recipes to make for parties this Holiday Season? These pop tarts are perfect for Christmas morning and this homemade dunkaroo recipe is a seriously delicious sweet […]

  4. […] this recipe get you feeling nostalgic? How about trying these homemade pop tarts? Another childhood […]

  5. Christina says:

    I bet these taste ten times better than the commercial ones! Love those Hand pies!

  6. These look so cute and delicious. 100% better than the store bought brand. I’m certain I will be trying these!

  7. Katie says:

    These are so fun! I’m so obsessed with pop tarts right now — we just made Circus Animal ones for the blog and OH MAN. They’re so fun and easy and everyone is always like, “You homemade pop tarts?!” Haha.

    Katie
    http://www.freckleandfair.com

  8. Those look fabulous! And much more healthy than the store bought option. My daughter will love these. Bookmarking for later 🙂

  9. So pretty! I’m also crushing pretty hard on your rolling pin… anthropology?!

  10. Homemade is the way to go with poptarts, easy and so much better for you! Looks absolutely delicious, and beautiful photography!!!

  11. What a great idea, these look amazing! I can’t wait to try them.

  12. This is amazing!!! I am definitely going to have to try this!

  13. Julia says:

    I have always wanted to make homemade pop tarts and yours look soo good I might just have to finally do so. I know my kids would love them

  14. Krystal says:

    Those look so good! I can’t wait to surprise my kids with these on Sunday.

  15. Ninz says:

    They look amazing hun! I think im in a baking mood this week so i might give them a try. On Sunday I made my first Valentines cupcakes and they turned out pretty cute. Love your blog!
    Ninz xxx

  16. Iman Brooks says:

    <3 My sons two favorite things pop tarts and strawberries.

  17. Amber says:

    These look amazing!

  18. Ashley says:

    How cute and yummy!

    -Ashley
    Le Stylo Rouge

  19. Mónica Sors says:

    Wow, seems so so good 😉

    XX

    Mónica Sors

    MES VOYAGES À PARIS

    NEW POST: TRAVEL OUTFIT, AMSTERDAM

  20. Angela Donava says:

    Looking so yummy!
    Have a nice evening!
    Angela Donava
    http://www.lookbooks.fr/

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

experiencing yves rocher in la gacilly

Last month I had the pleasure of experiencing Yves Rocher, one of my favourite beauty and skincare brands, first hand in the town where the brand originated – La Gacilly, France

read next:

+

-

+

-

READ MORE

on instagram

@threadsandblooms

Follow along with our daily snaps featuring all things home, garden, and floral design